zdw 12 hours ago

Having used multiple code review tools (Gerrit, Phabricator), GitHub's code review is frankly one of the worst UX's for humans to use for this purpose (go try to review a rebased patchset, or have to wade through the inefficient use of space in the UI), so I'm not surprised AI has trouble with it as well.

  • bckmn 11 hours ago

    Agreed. I think this is why we’re seeing a lot of new wrappers being built like Graphite.

    • jacobegold 10 hours ago

      a lot? what are the other ones?

      • bckmn 10 hours ago

        In exploring `gh` CLI extensions recently I found at least 2 devoted to being a better PR review interface. I've also seen [Trag](https://usetrag.com/) and others pop up.

      • codeapprove 7 hours ago

        Some others which are good:

          * Reviewable
          * Codestream (formerly GitContext)
          * Codelantis
          * CodeApprove (biased, obviously)